There are 22 Pitcher's Nightmare trading cards tracked on HobbyCardIndex, spanning Baseball. The most valuable is the Pitcher's Nightmare [Golden Mirror SSP Variation] #405 at $35.00 raw.
Source: HobbyCardIndex · Updated daily · https://hobbycardindex.com/players/pitcher-s-nightmarePitcher's Nightmare Cards
22 cards · Baseball
All Pitcher's Nightmare Cards
Pitcher's Nightmare [Golden Mirror SSP Variation] #405
$35.00
Pitcher's Nightmare [Memorial Day Camo] #405
$29.99
Pitcher's Nightmare [Mother's Day Pink] #405
$17.12
Pitcher's Nightmare [Black] #405
$10.00
Pitcher's Nightmare [Vintage Stock] #405
$7.00
Pitcher's Nightmare [Father's Day Blue] #405
$6.50
Pitcher's Nightmare [Independence Day] #405
$5.50
Pitcher's Nightmare [Orange] #405
$3.72
Pitcher's Nightmare [Red Foil] #405
$2.78
Pitcher's Nightmare [Royal Blue] #405
$2.75
Pitcher's Nightmare [Orange Foil] #405
$2.66
Pitcher's Nightmare [Gold] #405
$1.99
Pitcher's Nightmare [Blue Foil] #405
$1.99
Pitcher's Nightmare [Purple Foil] #405
$1.95
Pitcher's Nightmare [Gold Foil] #405
$1.75
Pitcher's Nightmare #405
$1.74
Pitcher's Nightmare [All Star Game] #405
$1.65
Pitcher's Nightmare [Rainbow Foil] #405
$1.55
Pitcher's Nightmare [Green Foil] #405
$1.49
Pitcher's Nightmare [Purple] #405
$1.42
Pitcher's Nightmare #405
$1.20
Pitcher's Nightmare [Gold Star] #405
$0.99