Magic Exodus Recurring Nightmare is currently valued at $58.90 raw (ungraded) and $94.00 in PSA 9. Prices are based on recent sold listings from eBay, Goldin, Heritage Auctions, and other marketplaces.
Source: HobbyCardIndex · Updated daily · https://hobbycardindex.com/cards/3578699
Magic Exodus Recurring Nightmare
As of , Recurring Nightmare sells for about $58.90 raw and $94.00 in PSA 9, based on HobbyCardIndex's aggregated market pricing.
- Set: Magic Exodus
- Last updated:
- Catalog ID: 17901
Magic: The Gathering
· Magic · Magic Exodus
Current Market Prices
Prices updated daily from multiple market sources.
Raw / Ungraded
$58.90
PSA 10
N/A
PSA 9
$94.00
PSA 8
$49.69
BGS 10
$128.50
CGC 10
$136.69
SGC 10
N/A
Card Details
| Brand | Magic |
| Set | Magic Exodus |
| Category | Magic: The Gathering |
Recent Sold Listings
-
Magic: The Gathering Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72Raw$42.99Nov 19, 2026
-
Recurring Nightmare Exodus LP MTG Magic: The Gathering Card-Raw$67.83Nov 15, 2026
-
Magic: The Gathering Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72Raw$42.00Nov 14, 2026
-
Magic: The Gathering Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72Raw$58.49Nov 14, 2026
-
Magic: The Gathering Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72Raw$89.98Nov 11, 2026
-
***CGC 10 Recurring Nightmare*** MTG Exodus Magic Kid IcarusCGC 10$136.69Nov 10, 2026
-
Magic: The Gathering Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72Raw$58.99Nov 7, 2026
-
Recurring Nightmare - Exodus 1998 MTG - Pristine Near Mint (NM) - Reserved ListRaw$51.50Nov 7, 2026
-
Magic: The Gathering Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72Raw$72.68Nov 6, 2026
-
Magic: The Gathering Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72Raw$70.70Nov 2, 2026
-
Magic: The Gathering Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72Raw$43.30Nov 2, 2026
-
Magic: The Gathering Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72Raw$71.14Nov 2, 2026
-
Magic: The Gathering Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72Raw$70.00Nov 1, 2026
-
Recurring Nightmare HP / DMG Exodus MTG Magic The GatheringRaw$49.99Nov 1, 2026
-
Magic: The Gathering Exodus Recurring Nightmare #72Raw$43.30Oct 31, 2026