There are 92 Nightmare trading cards tracked on HobbyCardIndex, spanning Magic: The Gathering, Marvel, Other, Football. The most valuable is the Nightmare at $987.50 raw.
Source: HobbyCardIndex · Updated daily · https://hobbycardindex.com/players/nightmareNightmare Cards
92 cards · Magic: The Gathering Marvel Other Football
All Nightmare Cards
Nightmare
$987.50
Nightmare [Golden Treasures] #WI47
$952.42
Nightmare [Golden Treasures] #61
$499.00
Nightmare
$408.90
Nightmare [Seismic Gold] #47
$174.33
Nightmare [Amber Crystals] #WI47
$109.50
Nightmare [Precious Metal Gems Red] #61
$104.25
Nightmare #412
$103.75
Nightmare [Seismic Gold Variant] #61-V
$100.00
Nightmare [Foil]
$93.00
Nightmare [Seismic Gold] #61
$83.00
Nightmare [Cosmic] #47
$52.28
Nightmare [Alternate]
$51.00
Nightmare #115
$40.00
Nightmare [Cosmic] #WI47
$38.52
Nightmare [Orange Checkers] #47
$25.00
Nightmare [Pink Pulsar] #47
$18.83
Nightmare [Pink Lasers] #61
$18.49
Nightmare [Purple Pixels] #47
$17.78
Nightmare #61
$16.25
Nightmare #119
$15.86
Nightmare
$15.00
Nightmare #23
$11.43
Nightmare [Red Prism] #61
$10.99
Nightmare [Blue Traxx Variant] #61-V
$10.00
Nightmare [Purple Crystals] #61
$9.97
Nightmare [Foil]
$9.75
Nightmare
$8.69
Nightmare #120
$7.77
Nightmare
$7.00
Nightmare [Holofoil] #61
$6.99
Nightmare [Green Crackle] #47
$6.24
Nightmare [Lenticular] #61
$4.99
Nightmare [Blue Surge] #47
$3.99
Nightmare [Variant Cover] #23
$3.99
Nightmare [Variant] #61-V
$3.99
Nightmare #127
$3.98
Nightmare [Red Prism] #47
$3.62
Nightmare [Rainbow] #47
$3.57
Nightmare [Yellow Rainbow] #47
$3.19
Nightmare [Rainbow Variant] #61-V
$3.03
Nightmare [Blue Traxx] #61
$2.99
Nightmare [Rainbow] #61
$2.98
Nightmare #30
$2.97
Nightmare [Gold Signature Series] #23
$2.50
Nightmare [Blue Traxx] #47
$2.41
Nightmare #WI47
$2.27
Nightmare
$2.26
Nightmare [Clear Cut] #61
$2.00
Nightmare [Canvas] #61
$1.99
Nightmare #47
$1.99
Nightmare [Red Rainbow] #47
$1.99
Nightmare #61
$1.74
Nightmare
$1.59
Nightmare #56
$1.59
Nightmare [Foil]
$1.57
Nightmare
$1.56
Nightmare [Foil]
$1.55
Nightmare #42
$1.55
Nightmare [Teal Wave] #47
$1.53
Nightmare [Black Rainbow] #47
$1.46
Nightmare #61
$1.38
Nightmare #108
$1.15
Nightmare [Yellow Spotlight] #47
$1.14
Nightmare
$1.00
Nightmare [Rainbow] #WI47
$0.99
Nightmare [Blue Rainbow] #47
$0.99
Nightmare [Purple Rainbow] #47
$0.99
Nightmare [Foil]
$0.79
Nightmare
$0.69
Nightmare
$0.55
Nightmare #WC-14
$0.50
Nightmare
$0.40
Nightmare #17
$0.38
Nightmare [Token] #6
$0.32
Nightmare #17
$0.30
Nightmare
$0.25
Nightmare
$0.25
Nightmare [Foil]
$0.22
Nightmare
$0.20
Nightmare
$0.19
Nightmare [Foil]
$0.18
Nightmare
$0.15
Nightmare [Foil]
$0.15
Nightmare #8
$0.12
Nightmare
—
Nightmare
—
Nightmare [Gold] #127
—
Nightmare [Autograph] #61
—
Nightmare #V12
—
Nightmare [Autograph] #61
—
Nightmare [Printing Plate] #127
—